“I used to be a huge fan of this podcast but lately it seems like Arden is being held at gun point to be there. Also their habit of naming everyone on the roster in one explanation has gotten extremely old. I will still listen because it can sometimes be fun and can definitely be informative from...”Read full review »
“My Jays addiction is fed with the show and I look forward to it- sometimes a little too MBA -Khaki for me (enjoy yourselves boys!) but all in all a good show.”
“Hard to believe only 2 episodes remaining of from our favourite Blue Jays podcasters. A tumultuous year for Jays fans, put into perspective each week by BNS & Arden. We miss you already…enjoy the off-season!”
wantedtoloke via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
10/07/23
“Always listen to this great pod, sometimes twice. I just noticed this morning you’ve changed the theme music….good work…not sure how long ago that happened because I would skip the first three minutes so I didn’t have to hear the old tune. Great job guys.”
“I have been listening to this podcast for several years. Ben and Arden offer a fresh take on baseball commentary. They are well researched and help expand your knowledge of baseball. MUY BUENO!!!”
Antonio Muoff via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
08/08/23
“Great show, guys. The two of you make a great duo with your slightly different areas of focus or personal interest but similarly humble personalities and down-to-earth style (unlike a certain former colleague of yours’). Really looking forward to your annual over/under episode in a few weeks…...”Read full review »
“Always top-notch analysis, providing a fair and objective view of the Jays. I’d give five stars but the boys can get a little self-involved at times. Love you both, truly, and I badly want to hear your analysis. But the tangents about your own long days and travelling and what it’s like to be...”Read full review »
Mac Fenwick via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
02/25/23
“Yours is one of the podcast that makes the ball season for me, something to look forward to. Whatever the content, blue jays or just baseball in general.”
The Town123 via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
02/10/23
“We’re heading for the coldest weather in 20 years (-18° temp and -40° windchill) and you’re talking about baseball! Wonderful. I’m going to enjoy every episode. Glad you both had good off-seasons looking after yourselves. Have a great year.”
Witch's cat via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
02/02/23
“Wow! If I didn’t know better I would think this is a podcast about a 100 loss team! No need for a completely homer Jays podcast, but a little positivity would’ve helped. The first third was an ode to Aaron Judge and the next third only criticism of the young players on the team. Went to listen to...”Read full review »
“The content is awesome. The problem is major things happen like trades or season starting, and there is no urgency for reaction. Over/unders haven’t been posted over a week into the season, 3 days since vladdys 3HR game, still no content. I’ll find my content elsewhere where the effort is there...”Read full review »
“A good solid pod for great blue jays news and interviews. The ‘hey Rogers has spent a lot of money, maybe they can’t extend both Vlad and Bo’ talk is not wrong per se—but it’s mentioned very frequently and getting pretty predictable. I generally expect to hear a comment that turns down the heat...”Read full review »
1reviewonly via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
01/28/22
“No one can put me to sleep faster than these two guys, a great sleep aid. Also Arden finishes his sentences with “right” way too much, very annoying habit many have in broadcasting.”
“Been listening for almost 3 years now, these guys are in a great rhythm and are a good mix. You can tell Ben is a writer by how he lays out his position very methodically, and I think Arden would be great with a radio show - drives conversations super easily and has a lot of interesting takes....”Read full review »
“I downloaded a bunch of Blue Jay podcasts and their podcast is the only one I consistently come back to. They are interesting and intelligent about how they approach their podcast. Definitely the best Blue Jays podcast out there.”
Bob #21 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/09/21
“Have been a loyal listener to ATL for three years now however I am questioning my dedication due to Arden Zwelling’s questionable expert analysis the past two weeks. He suggested that moving Bichette off of shortshop may hurt his feelings! Isn’t this the big leagues? Then he stated that good...”Read full review »
“I enjoy Mr. Nicholson-Smith’s commentary, which is the reason I gave this podcast three stars. Unfortunately, I find Mr. Zwelling difficult to listen to. He appears to think the “average” fan is fully represented by Jays’ Twitter. He spends a good deal of his airtime setting up straw man...”Read full review »
“The last several episodes in 2021 have featured 4-5 moments in each episode where the editing and cutting has been abysmal.
It's becoming an issue when I'm consistently having to fast forward throughout the episode in order to avoid having to listen to what was just said 15-20 seconds...”Read full review »
Toronto Dan via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
03/14/21
“This used to be a great baseball podcast. Now you get 45 mins about the hosts view on covid or other issues then 15 mins of actual blue Jay’s talk. Spin rate is much better. Go back to talking baseball.”
saunders315 via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
03/13/21
“Definitely one of the best Jays podcasts. Though I have a constructive criticism. Perhaps improve the quality control before publishing. It seems like every podcast has at least one editing error, where parts of the podcast are repeated.
It’s strange that a podcast produced by a media...”Read full review »
vancity_jaysfan via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
03/12/21
“Rogers can’t allow for open opinion of its product on this podcast, and how could they? They’re a major corporation. The way they made excuses for the execs in the Mickey Callaway scandal was just gross. Corporate shills at root. I prefer honest analysis.”