Murder in Chatham: Virginia & Alfred Critchley and Jasen Pangburn
Listen now
Episode 237: On a fall evening in 1991, police discovered the bodies of Alfred Critchley, 75, and Virginia Critchley, 73, in the Chatham, Ontario residence they shared with their son and his family. The couple had been brutally stabbed. Alfred was unconscious but alive and Virginia was barely alive. Virginia died in the ambulance on the way to the hospital and Alfred died later in the hospital having never regained consciousness. After a brief search, the couple’s grandson, Jasen Pangburn, 19, was discovered partially buried in a nearby ravine. Jasen had been executed with a single gunshot to the chest from a .22 calibre firearm. Thanks to Virginia’s dying words, suspicion fell on two youths, who’d been acquaintances of Jasen Pangburn’s, Jason Shawn Cofell, 18, and a 15-year-old accomplice we’ll call C.B. Sources: 2007 CanLII 76511 (ON SC) | R. v. Cofell | CanLII The Essex and Kent Scottish - Chatham triple-murderer granted parole after almost 25 years in prison | CBC News Teenage triple-murderer whose killings rocked Chatham, region gets parole after decades in prison Search — Jason Shaw Cofell — Cofell, Jason – Canadian Crimeopedia Chatham-Kent, ON Crime Rates & Map Learn more about your ad choices. Visit
More Episodes
Episode 246: John Ruffolo, 36, an employee of Brinks Canada at Butler Crescent location in Saanichton, British Columbia, was due to start a night shift at 10:30 PM on October 19, 2003. He was an ATM technician and an armoured car driver. When John didn’t show up, the rest of the armoured car crew...
Published 11/28/22
Episode 245: Between 1926 and 1928, a sinister darkness was afoot on a small chicken ranch in Wineville, California. When he was only 19, Gordon Stewart Northcott, a Canadian, had abducted, raped, tortured and murdered at least three and as many as 20 others. His victims were predominantly...
Published 11/21/22