Reviews
I’ve been a fan for 5 years, and the show has always been a bright spot in my week! Both with Gilmore and now Maisel, this podcast balances delighting in the worlds Amy has created with being critical as needed (which is pretty often). And everything is done with the goal of bringing...Read full review »
Heksindkiwhebd via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/25/20
I’ve listened to Gilmore Guys so many times. It has truly helped me tune out during some weird times.
canadang via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/23/20
Love Kevin and loved Gilmore Guys. I feel like Gilmore Guys was so fun and positive, and now Maisel Goys is just two people who hate a show. It’s so interesting because none of their guests seem to ever agree with them. The guests always like Maisel way more than Kevin and Alice and often Kevin...Read full review »
marigold x via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/23/20
I just discovered your podcast while rewatching Gilmore Girls for the umpteenth time! Thank you for giving us a lift and something to look forward to during this coronavirus mess! It is so much fun to watch an episode and then listen to you guys and your great guests! Thanks again for brightening...Read full review »
movie lover teacher via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/22/20
I’m writing this review in the middle of the COVID-19 Crisis and since we’re all social distancing I’ve been looking for a podcast to binge. And let me tell you, this is a delight! I just started listening - I was a fan of Gilmore Girls when it was airing and so it definitely reminds me of my...Read full review »
mellie_melly via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/14/20
I just started listening, and I’m not going in any particular order... but find the chatter nice. I’m currently on ep 520 where one of them said “stuff you should know,” “that should be a podcast.” And the other guy said no that sounds dumb 😂 Idk if this is a poke at SYSK but it’s my fav...Read full review »
rantingismybestskil via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/04/20
Gilmore Guys is a gem, truly the only reason I started watching the original show was so I could understand the jokes between Demi and Kevin. And then “Marvelous Mrs Maisel” came on and the show is great and worth discussing but more and more I look less to wanting to hear it discussed here....Read full review »
IncTime. via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/26/20
I’ve probably listened to this podcast more times than I’d like to admit, but it’s become a warmer blanket to me than the actual Gilmore Girls show at this point. I think Kevin is probably one of the best podcast hosts/producers in the medium. This show has also introduced me to so many other...Read full review »
Adam LeClair via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/25/20
I love the early episodes when it was about the Gilmore girls! Not a fan of the newer episodes. Gilmore girls season was great!
keephopealive! via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/25/20
I just got on the Gilmore Guys wagon so I know I’m late to everything lol but I loved Demi & Kevin’s lightheartedness and how fun the show was when they talked about Gilmore Girls, I’m already on Bunhead Bros and they’re the reason I’m watchin Bunheads right now. I really hate to do this, but...Read full review »
truecrimefann via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/25/20
Thanks for getting me through some tough times. None of my friends like Gilmore Girls so it’s nice to listen to this as I rewatch for the 90th time! :)
critzker via Apple Podcasts · Canada · 02/20/20
I started listening to Gilmore Guys with the Gilmore Girls podcast and then followed the journey to Bunhead Bros. I was ecstatic when I learned about Maisel Guys to experience another lovely series with Kevin and Demi. However Alice has made the experience unbearable. She has nothing positive to...Read full review »
rabellie via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/19/20
I enjoyed the original Gilmore Guys episodes. Demi and Kevin has a great dynamic and brought fun tangents. The Maisel Episodes aren’t the same. There is simply something missing and when Alice says “I don’t want to do this podcast with you anymore...” I find myself wishing she’d step away.
Pandapics via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/17/20
I have listened to every episode, hundreds of hours. Never seen any of the shows.
suzetteicidal via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/12/20
Update 2/2020: first thing first...Gilmore Girls fans, absolutely DO listen to the Gilmore Girls episodes with Kevin and Demi-they are super fun!!! See below.* BUT the Maisel episodes wow wow wow wow wow Has Alice doubled down and trying even harder to come across as completely obnoxious and...Read full review »
SurferKitty via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/12/20
Kevin is sweet and kind and intellectual and reflective. His Maisel cohost, Alice thinks she is HILARIOUS. She’s not. Her constant sarcasm is her brand I guess, but it comes across to me as smarmy and know it all. Yuck. I love Mrs Maisel so I was so happy Kevin was doing a podcast. But this Alice...Read full review »
podpeople100 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/10/20
The first couple season of Gilmore gurls are truest master pieces. I love listening to new podcast and hearing them learn how to make one. It is rough there are time I did skip when thing got long winded but honestly stick it out they are great!
podkastjunkie via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/04/20
I LOVE The Gilmore Guys. It was happy, funny and positive. But Maisel Goys. Yeesh. Alice clearly doesn’t have any of those points of view. On anything. I miss the lightness Kevin and Demi shared
Akgraves via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/04/20
You have good things to say but so does everyone else. It makes it hard to listen to this show. It’s ok to slow down and listen to other people every once in awhile. Conversation is a give and take...
rsumj via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/03/20
I really enjoy this podcast. But come on Kevin. You claim to be a fan but you think Taylor’s last name is pronounced “Do-see” when they say it plenty in the show to know it’s pronounced “Dough-see”. It’s nitpicking I know. But you can’t claim to be a fan and not know that.
ensiwmbri via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/03/20
Could Alice try and be a bit more positive? I feel like she is always infuriated/angry but SOMETHING that was or wasn’t done. I just wish it could be a bit more positive and talk about what both Kevin and Alice DID enjoy as opposed to the seemingly endless complaining.
mazel2020 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 01/28/20
I have rewatched GG so many times so how have I not found you before?! Perfect format pc for total fans - despite the frequent off-tangent discussions. TY TY TY (Team Logan , yes we do exist!)
couldeyecormin via Apple Podcasts · Great Britain · 01/26/20
I’m very late to join the Gilmore Guys Train. But I just got into Podcasting about a year ago. Have almost listened to this whole podcast twice. I absolutely love Aisha Muharrar and Sarah Heyward. I could not relate to them more about their love for Gilmore Girls. I too cannot count how many...Read full review »
Danielle_Gjesdal via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 01/23/20
Fun to listen to, they do veer off topic a lot but it’s still entertaining
Shesyourqueentobe via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 01/11/20
As a younger viewer that loves movies and tv (pop culture in general) this podcast is just amazing to me. I love the witty jokes and conversations between Kevin and Demi or Alice on anything! I love Bunheads, Gilmore, and Maisel so much and my appreciation grows when I listen to how in depth...Read full review »
wish it were the same via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 12/20/19
I never knew I wanted a Gilmore Girls podcast until I listened this. It’s unorganised, it’s rarely on the rails, it focuses an alarming amount of its run time on fashion, and it is perfect in every way. Who would have thought that listening to two guys and various guests sing the theme song...Read full review »
MovieManiac78 via Apple Podcasts · New Zealand · 12/03/19
If you’re someone who hates tangents and is looking for a thorough review of each episode, this may not be for you. Keep listening or try later episodes as the hosts find their footing. With that being said, I really enjoy the “Gilmore Gabs” with the cast/crew members of the TV show who are all...Read full review »
Al_loween702 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 12/02/19
So, Im currently listening the Marvelous Mrs Maisel part of the podcast (season 2) and, honestly lately is so much hate over it that im getting kind of mad at the hosts... You are starting to look more like 2 entitled critics more than anything and is not enjoyable anymore. You just analice with...Read full review »
Parropita via Apple Podcasts · Spain · 11/24/19
I was compelled by the “They Shoot Gilmores Don’t They” episode to actually leave a review. I’ve been binging the podcast for a few days now (sometimes with Gilmore Girls playing on mute in the background...) and finally had to skip ahead to the podcast ep about my all time favorite GG episode...Read full review »
trAsh Candiboot via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 11/18/19
I restarted this podcast and I’m back with the original hosts talking Gilmore Girls. Their chemistry is great and they’re hilarious!
beanscene12313 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 11/14/19
I’m only in the realm of Gilmore Girls right now, but that doesn’t even matter cause these guys are great! Actually, I couldn’t care less about Gilmore Girls, I just fully enjoy listening to Kevin and Demi riff off one another and the odd places the conversations land! Lots of suppressed...Read full review »
Spunkii2483 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 11/12/19
A great podcast!
SGJ88 via Apple Podcasts · Australia · 11/09/19
I am a G.Girls faithful but have only began to listen to G.Guys and am nearly finished Season One. The guys are hilarious and I now refer to Chad Michael Mudface. I definitely argue with the guys often, and worry that my American pop-culture is better as an Aussie than them, but maybe its because...Read full review »
Annieone84 via Apple Podcasts · Australia · 10/27/19
Biggest mistake I made was binge listening to this show because now I need to wait for a weekly basis and it’s awful! I love Sam and Emily and truly feel like their familiar friends and my only gripe is they only do one podcast a week. They make me love Harry Potter even more.
Timi Kelly via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/27/19
This show got me through my very long commute, but now that my commute is shorter I find their extremely long podcasts less fun. And Kevin gets barely tolerable as the seasons go by. Demi is a gem.
meg211713 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/26/19
It’s so funny people have reviews that say “who would listen for 2-4 hours” when they had thousands of thousands of people that listened to every minute of every episode for literally years when they did this podcast! I’ve listened to every episode and am making my way back through the podcast...Read full review »
carolinekthornton via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/10/19
I absolutely love this show and finally decided to check out a podcast for it. This was probably the wrong one. Some conversations are good but for the most part it’s hard to get through. Made it to season 5 and trying to finish.
justOCB via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/21/19
I finished binging Gilmore Girls on Netflix a few weeks ago. In the search for more podcasts to listen to, I stumbled on this one. These first few episodes can be difficult to listen to because they go off on so many tangents and the lack of editing to resolve it, but it’s part of their growth to...Read full review »
jenriquez2020 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/14/19
Love the concept, really wanted to love this. But where is the editing? Where do you get off thinking people want to listen to 3-5 hours of you talking about anything, much less the unbearable Year in the Life season? Are you kidding me?? Even the 1-3 hour episodes are in desperate need of...Read full review »
realmareva via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/09/19
Just found this podcast a few months ago. I grew up with Gilmore Girls, being about the same age as Rory when it started. I listen while I’m at work, and get funny looks when I bust out laughing with my headphones in. Love this podcast!
crose1210 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/08/19
I didn’t start watching Gilmore Girls till 2017, and started listening along with the podcast. I finished the show a while ago, but am still working through the podcast (the podcast episodes are just a little longer than the show episodes ;) ) I have laughed out loud so many times, many hours of...Read full review »
Emily M via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/04/19
This has been fun to listen to. I’m a big GilGirls fan. As a huge pop culture fan I get all the crazy obscure references! It’s funny to hear your take on this show.
romanafour4 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 07/31/19
One of my professors recommended this podcast to me because I LOVE Gilmore Girls. I’ve watched every season 7 times so far. Once I started listening to this podcast, I couldn’t stop. Demi and Kevin are so funny and both offer different points of view to the show. Must listen if you love Gilmore...Read full review »
Mrs. Zebra via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 07/10/19
The Gilmore Girls section has long ended, but I’m still coming back to re-listen. So good and so funny. Miss you Gilmore Guys!
Alopie124 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 07/09/19
These boys always keep me coming back to re-listen to episodes. It is hilarious and incredible. The things that Kevin comes up with on the fly is hilarious. I have laughed about “insomnia Barabbus” for years.
Anonymously257 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 06/29/19
This was painful to Listen to. A lot of complains and way too many tangents. There are much better podcasts. I hate when a podcast goes on their own tangent.
Yellowstars123 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 06/27/19
I thought I was alone. Alice is very hard to listen to. I stopped listening because of her POV is too tiring. Also i like how Demi and Kevin could easily talk for hours and I didn’t mind it wasnt about gg. (Troli love)
wisae via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 06/13/19
A test of a good podcast is feeling like you are friends with the hosts. This podcast passes that test at the detriment of all other tests, and I couldn’t be happier.
Zucati via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 06/10/19
K, love you bye.
ElleRitch via Apple Podcasts · Canada · 05/24/19
I really tried to like this podcast as I’ve been a Gilmore girls fan from the beginning. I feel like I’m listening to a podcast about many many random things with a little bit of Gilmore girls thrown in. And most of it is stuff they don’t like. Ummm, why then did you dedicate hours to creating a...Read full review »
Coza 22 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 05/11/19
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from iTunes, Stitcher and more.
See hourly chart positions and more than 30 days of history.
Get Chartable Analytics »