Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF18, the third episode of Season Twenty-Four, Adventures in Baby-Getting. They talk about pregnancy, communication, and learning cursive. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite movie with a baby in it?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF17, Treehouse of Horror XXIII, the second episode of Season Twenty-Four. They talk about horror, time travel, and black holes. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite ghost story?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF21, Moonshine River, the first episode of Season Twenty-Four. They talk about Mary Spuckler, 9/11 jokes, and Shakespeare in the park. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite story (book, movie, TV, comic book) that takes place in NYC?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF14, Lisa Goes Gaga, the final episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about Lady Gaga, commercials, and celebrity worship. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite moment from Season Twenty-Three?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF15, Ned ‘n’ Edna’s Blend Agenda, the twenty-first episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about marriage, Rod & Todd, and the passion play. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What is your favorite Ned Flanders quote?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF13, The Spy Who Learned Me, the twentieth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about James Bond, childhood obesity, and the passage of time. Pre-Order Robbie’s next book, THIS BOOK IS CURSED Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week – What is your favorite Simpsons quote about food?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF12, A Totally Fun Thing That Bart Will Never Do Again, the nineteenth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about cruise ships, Homer’s behavior, and basic competency. Pre-Order THIS BOOK IS CURSED Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: Favorite quote in a travel episode?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF11, Beware My Cheating Bart, the eighteenth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about Lost, gross stuff, and what is wrong with The Simpsons writers. Pre-Order THIS BOOK IS CURSED Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What is your favorite quote from the bullies?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF10, Them, Robot, the seventeenth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about robots, drug testing, and tiny violins. Pre-order Robbie’s new novel, THIS BOOK IS CURSED Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite Barney quote?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF08, How I Wet Your Mother, the sixteenth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about Inception, bed-wetting, and letting Mona die. Pre-Order THIS BOOK IS CURSED Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite dream sequence in The Simpsons?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF09, Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart, the fifteenth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about lazy storytelling, street art, and deplorable parenting. Pre-order THIS BOOK IS CURSED! Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite Snake Jailbird quote?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF07, At Long Last Leave, the fourteenth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about Julian Assange, lack of conflict, and special episodes. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite Kent Brockman quote?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF06, The Daughter Also Rises, the thirteenth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about Lisa, Hemingway, and utter shame. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week – What’s your favorite Mythbusters myth?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie are joined by Greg TeGantvoort to discuss Episode PABF05, Moe Goes from Rags to Riches, the twelfth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about bar rags, Jeremy Irons, and yetis. Subscribe to the Cult Video Vault! Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite Jeremy Irons project?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF04, The D’oh-cial Network, the eleventh episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about social media, Edward Gorey, and phones. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite late night talk show moment?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF03, Politically Inept, with Homer Simpson, the tenth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about political satire, talking heads, and Ted Nugent. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite viral video?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie answer YOUR questions and reminisce on 500 episodes of the podcast! This will be our last episode of 2023! Happy Holidays!

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode NABF18, Holidays of Future Passed, the ninth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about flash-forwards, joke shotguns, and drunk Lisa. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Next week: The 500th Episode Holiday Mailbag Spectacular!

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF02, The Ten-Per-Cent Solution, the eighth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about Joan Rivers, Krusty, and retreads. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your idea for a Krusty episode?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode PABF01, The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants, the seventh episode of Season Twenty- Three. They talk about Mad Men, bad fourth acts, and parody. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite commercial of all time?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode NABF22, The Book Job, the sixth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about Neil Gaiman, publishing, and heist movies. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What was your favorite childhood book?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode NABF20, The Food Wife, the fifth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about food, meth labs, and molecular gastronomy. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite episode written by Matt Selman?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode NABF21, Replaceable You, the fourth episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about robot seals, Jane Lynch, and fever dreams. Support the show on the Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: Who’s your favorite robot character?

Tonight, Matt and Robbie discuss Episode NABF19, Treehouse of Horror XXII, the third episode of Season Twenty-Three. They talk about lack of scares, lack of laugh, and lack of effort. Support the show on Patreon! Subscribe to our subreddit! Listener Question of the Week: What’s your favorite horror sequel?