It’s alright?
To preface I’m definitely an obsessive, have rewatched all the way through at least 10 times. Dan and Roberta are lively and do a good job of not just recapping but having some discussion of dialogue, themes in an episode, etc. I was hoping for something more in depth. There are other die hards like me and it’s a tough crowd to please for sure. Often there are minor mistakes in recalling lines or scenes which feels a little excruciating. Like if you’re hosting a podcast, maybe watch the episode twice? The hosts will go back and forth about something that could be resolved with a simple rewatching of a scene. “Arguing about facts” as Pete’s mom would say haha. Sometimes they spend wayy too much time on esoterics- some general ‘feeling’ of an episode or scene but very little specifics as to how or why or what it means? Especially since this show is so intentional with set design, costuming, line inflection, callbacks in the dialogue… you know, the things that make it so rewatchable. One good point has been the exploration of Jewish themes and nuances that I’m not knowledgeable of. Also the guests are great!
nickcirca1933 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 12/24/21
More reviews of They Coined It, a Mad Men Podcast
If you’re a mad men fan this is a great pod for you! Quit messing around and subscribe already
Fernoates via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/04/21
I’m already big Mad Men re-watcher so I feel like I know the show in and out, but its a pleasure to hear these two intelligently debate and discuss the show to where I feel like I’m getting even more out of the original content. The pace and rapport of these hosts is pleasant and I’m finding...Read full review »
Jasmin193 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/29/21
If you’ve never watched Mad Men, this is a great accompaniment to watching it for the first time (lucky you). For this long time fan it’s a great trip back through each episode from the start of season one, led by people who really know the show and have the best insights. So nice to have this...Read full review »
Stixx74 via Apple Podcasts · Great Britain · 08/21/20
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.
See hourly chart positions and more than 30 days of history.
Get Chartable Analytics »