Dan and Fran Keller operated a successful and loving daycare until one day everything was turned upside down. A child came forward with a horrific story of abuse, sparking widespread panic and hysteria from all directions.

John List was regarded by many as a devout and pious man, whose unwavering dedication to his faith was apparent to those around him. However, on the morning of November 9, 1971, this seemingly godly man's life took a dark and horrific turn. On that day, John List awoke and carried out an...