“… which is a recurring disappointment to an incredibly interesting podcast and important period of history. She succumbs almost inevitably to the mistake of determining a ‘British’ action (lazily using the term for both the British state and the East India Company) as the ultimate cause of subsequent evils, glossing over anything which doesn’t quite fit this narrative. On the mutiny, for example, Christian missionaries seeking to convert Indians are the cause of the bloodshed, rather than the sepoys who started the killing. The British violence against Indians retaking Delhi is abhorrent, the Sepoy violence against Indians in taking the city in the first place passes without comment. That the Sepoys fled on the coming of the eclipse is bad luck - I’d say it was bad planning. Dalrymple refuses to challenge any of this, leading to a thoroughly biased collection of half truths. It needs Dominic Sandbrook on board stat.”
Craigisme89 via Apple Podcasts ·
Great Britain ·
09/06/22