It’s a no from me
I gave this a go, I really did. But in terms of the content itself, it’s a strong ‘no’ from me. Annabelle is a talented host and is the saving grace of this whole podcast. 9 times out of 10 I fast forward past all the small talk to get to the secret, I listen to the secret, and then I mark the episode as ‘played’ and move along. Why? The discussion is boring, inane, and contributes nothing. I agree with the reviews below, which suggest bringing a qualified expert on board for heavier topics and which scald Annabelle and guests for laughing at sections of someone’s secret as it’s being read out - as if anyone would want their deepest darkest secrets laughed at?! Probably the weakest offering yet by the team at Shameless Media. Needs a big shakeup.
koolrats via Apple Podcasts · Australia · 10/07/22
More reviews of everybody has a secret
Okay I love this pod!!! Admittedly, I was a bit unsure at first and had the same “should they be giving advice” vibes but it’s actually so good and so entertaining!! It’s obviously not a psychology podcast (and i wouldn’t be super interested in that anyway), but it provides objective perspectives...Read full review »
embleach via Apple Podcasts · Australia · 06/24/22
Vacuous commentary and constant high pitched laughter makes this a really tough listen. The tone is so perky when much of the content of the secrets is pretty dark. I also really dislike the privilege evident in the hosts responses. 1 star
jojoindahouse via Apple Podcasts · Australia · 08/04/23
I was surprised to see so many negative reviews about Annabelle and the guests being unqualified to give advice. I think that is the greatest strength of the podcast. It keeps it light and reminiscent of a d&’m with friends where you bounce around ideas. Keep it up
Fjejwkwekek via Apple Podcasts · Australia · 06/21/22
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.