Every town has an Elm Street, and a real life Freddy Krueger lived near the one in Salida, California. In this episode, we discuss the camp and the cult led by Gerald Cruz responsible for the murders on Elm Street.

In part 2 of this unbelievable case, Laura conveys the unimaginable and confusing experience of kidnapped Denise Huskins, and we finally learn about Matthew Muller: the man behind the wetsuit.