“Here’s my ideas:
So I always assumed that the younger version and the regular version of person were two different..people, for lack of a better word. I would assume that the older version would not remember their time as the younger person, because they’re not the same people. This would contradict people who say Judeleigh is gross because Dr. Whittier was an old man when he met Brynleigh. (Which, tbh, I agree) But using this, River and Sam can’t be James and Monica BECAUSE THEY WOULD REMEMBER MEETING THEIR KIDS. Another thing-we have established that Penn made Brynleigh lose her memories at Elixir, and probably everyone else too. But would they already have lost their memories by coming to Elixir? So did Penn only affect people from the present? So I think I am correct about the two people thing, and I have a couple questions about my theory too.
1. Does Jude have his memories after he travelled to the future? Because you don’t keep your memories if you’re not in your time. He said he met Dr. Whittier (the old man he mentions) so did Dr. Whittier like fill him in or something? If Dr. Whittier filled him in, then that would suggest he remembers being Jude, which totally contradicts my theory of being two separate people.
2. Angel. If she is Angelica, (which, I think so), Angelica definetly does not remember being Angel, because no. Which would make sense using my theory that the timey whimy versions and the regular people are two different people.
Well, that’s all I have so far, and I just want to say season 4 is my absolute favorite, and keep up the awesomeness!!!!”
Mushroomsforlife via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/14/24