Hit or miss
The idea of this show is solid, but I think where it tends to miss is the host treating the subject of each episode as if it’s disposable fluff. On one hand, yes, we all understand this is silly internet stuff, but if it’s 100% trivial, why do an episode? There has to be a balance of also asking an interesting question - and treating it as an interesting question. I think Candice usually achieves the first, but often fails on the second, partly because of her cutesy delivery, but also because she seems determined to make everything seem light when it doesn’t need to be. I really, really like Nadira Goffe, who manages to effortlessly bland these two things. The latest ep on the new Bad Art Friend is a perfect example - smart, incisive, confident commentary that was also funny and charming. Make her the permanent co-host! She’s what a show like this needs.
Moxie24 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/11/24
More reviews of ICYMI
I love this podcast! It’s so good. I like the discussion of internet and race and find it very important. I do wish they could go a bit deeper. I don’t want to join the wine club.
rkrae13 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 07/03/21
I LOVE this podcast. I’m not too keen on conversational podcasts, but these hosts are funny, witty, insightful, and the 60 Second Download they do is amazing. I thoroughly enjoy hearing their perspective on current events in social media. Thank you for giving me something to look forward to every...Read full review »
Jtaa via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 04/22/21
I love how they use various internet ephemera as a jumping off point to talk about serious issues. The hosts have great chemistry and are very fun to listen to. The pacing is perfect: the episodes are bite-sized and they don’t waste 10 minutes on pointless banter or in-jokes.
MollieDuke via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 01/04/22
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.