SKIP TO 00:11:00 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! Welcome to Episode 187: Kutchie’s Key Lime Pie, A Quirky Internet Mystery! Around 2009, a flurry of bizarre, copy pasta-esque comments began appearing across the internet in droves. These strange comments referenced a now-defunct restaurant named Kutchie’s Café which allegedly sold the best key lime pie in the world, a pie capable of giving people “piegasms”, baked by “Captain Kutchie” himself. For the next 8 years, this unknown person posted...

SKIP TO 00:11:00 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! In 1995, Paranoia.com was a website dedicated to protecting free speech. Among the usual suspects were political leaning government conspiracy pages, pages dedicated to educating visitors about the use of illegal drugs, and anti-censorship arguments; However, the site also featured a dark underbelly of alternative beliefs like cannibalism, terrorism, pedophilia, and human trafficking. In today’s episode, Nat brings Aly all the way back to 1995 to...

SKIP TO 00:19:08 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S LISTENER STORIES!   Welcome to Episode 185.5: Listener Stories #28! This is the episode where our Haunties (aka listeners) write in with their first-person spooky tales of cryptids, ghosts, curses, and aliens AND where Nat & Aly unbox fan mail sent by listeners just like YOU. This week, we unbox mail from: Ed & Chris of Scared All the Time, Lex aka Ex Art Student, Emily W. Aka EmmyKat9, and Becky H! WHY WERE WE SENT A MY SCENE VESPA??????...

SKIP TO 00:15:00TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! Welcome to Episode 185: The 1933 Magenta Italy UFO Incident (The “First” Crashed UFO)! In 1933, an aircraft of unknown origin crashed in the small township of Magenta, Italy. At first suspecting it may be a failed launch from the German “Die Glocke” (anti-gravity experimental aircraft), Benito Mussolini’s best scientists and engineers raced to reverse engineer it. Ultimately they were unsuccessful, and after the Germans denied it was theirs, the...

SKIP TO 00:10:49 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! William Bill Cooper was known as the Godfather of Modern Conspiracies and his life’s work served as the inspiration for the hit TV series, “The X Files.” But when his book “Behold a Pale Horse” became publicly available to read, it introduced the public to a previously unseen underbelly of “patriot” based conspiracy theories which demonized the United States government. As Americans unraveled under threats of terrorism and violence, his radio...

SKIP TO 00:12:00 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! Welcome to Episode 183: Underwater UFOs and UFO/UAP Basics! Dive headfirst into a “UAP For Beginners” class with Aly. In this episode, we will discuss: The UAP Hearings of 2023, the long road to disclosure, common acronyms (what’s the difference between a UAP and a UFO anyway?), sketchy government misinformation over the years, and what the heck USOs are (unidentified submerged objects). We will also briefly discuss: The 1994 Michigan UFO...

SKIP TO 12:00 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! Back in the other dimension that was 2022, the luxury fashion house Balenciaga became embroiled in scandal after dropping several strange ads featuring child models surrounded by adult gifts, demonic ritual imagery, and BDSM themed bears. Some “eagle eyed” fans noticed some of the sets were dressed with documents related to child abuse... but how deep exactly does this rabbit hole go? Join us this week as Nat takes Aly along on another deep dive into...

Welcome to Episode 181: Paranormal Games to Play in the Dark, Volume 7! THERE’S NO INTRO THIS EPISODE!! Today, we continue with the fan-favorite series of supernatural games you can play by yourself…if you dare. On today’s series installment, Aly explains to Nat how to play two games that explore two childhood fears: monsters in the closet and spirits in the mirror. In the first game, The Closet Game, a series of simple steps purports to open up a portal that exists in all of our closets....

SKIP TO 00:42:16 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S LISTENER STORIES! Welcome to Episode 180.5: Listener Stories #27! This is the episode where our Haunties (aka listeners) write in with their first-person spooky tales of cryptids, ghosts, curses, and aliens AND where Nat & Aly unbox fan mail sent by listeners just like YOU. This week, we unbox mail from: Katelyn + Sydney, Omar M, Savy, Katrine, Tasha D, Kai + Hayden, Arielle G, and more! Listener stories from this week’s episode include: A...

SKIP TO 00:07:28 TO GET TO THE STORY! Welcome to Episode 180:The Most Haunted Taylor Swift Conspiracies! In 2006, Taylor burst onto the music scene as a teenage country pop sensation and has been smashing records ever since. But 2023 may have been Taylor’s best year yet as she was crowned Time Magazine Person of The Year and became a newly minted billionaire. Taylor Swift is one of the most popular artists to ever walk the earth and we are undoubtedly witnessing a pop star in her prime... but...

SKIP TO 00:18:50 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S EPISODE!   Welcome to Episode 179: The Menacing Not Deer of American Forests Feat. Scared All The Time. Have you ever heard of the Not Deer? The term “Not-Deer” is a modern phrase coined to describe a subset of a supernatural phenomena that has likely permeated North American folklore long before it was recorded in writing. As its name suggests, “Not Deer” refers specifically to wild deer found in forests which are not actually animals at all, but...

SKIP TO 00:07:41 TO GET TO THE STORY! Welcome to Episode 178: The Deepest Dive on The Jeffrey Epstein Conspiracy, Part 3! In the final installment of this especially deep dive Nat asks Aly what kind of “insurance policy” Epstein and Ghislane may have been in possession of. Listen to hear of the tangled web that connects the royal family, the 2016 election, and a baby farming ranch in New Mexico! Allegedly, this episode will haunt you forever. TIME STAMPS 00:00:00 - INTRO / PERSONAL...

SKIP TO 00:14:30 TO GET TO THE STORY! Welcome to Episode 177: The Deepest Dive on The Jeffrey Epstein Conspiracy, Part 2! In our second installment of the Jeffrey Epstein Conspiracy series nobody asked for, Nat takes Aly beneath the surface and examines the relationships that made up Epstein’s social network. Join us as we take a closer look at Ghislane’s staged IN-N-OUT photos, the Maxwell family history of “cyber security”, and Prince Andrew’s ugly fall from grace. TIME STAMPS 00:00:00 -...

SKIP TO 00:14:12 TO GET TO THE STORY! Welcome to Episode 176: The Deepest Dive on The Jeffrey Epstein Conspiracy, Part 1! In this special 3 part series, Nat takes Aly (against her will) deep into the mystery surrounding the life and death of disgraced financier, Jeffrey Epstein. Join us for what is definitely the most unhinged and “allegedly” controversial retelling of a tale that still holds the world captive. Whether you believe Jeffrey was an international spy, a relentless blackmailer, or...

SKIP TO 00:37:22 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S LISTENER STORIES!   Welcome to Episode 175.5: Listener Stories #25! This is the episode where our Haunties (aka listeners) write in with their first-person spooky tales of cryptids, ghosts, curses, and aliens AND where Nat & Aly unbox fan mail sent by listeners just like YOU. This week, we unbox mail from: Lily, Elizabeth P., Michelle W., Hannah M., Lexi L. & Jesse S., Chrissy & Aly & Flighty, and Nicole S.! Listener stories from this...

SKIP TO 00:17:22 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S EPISODE! Welcome to Episode 175: The Skinny Bob Internet Mystery! Beginning on April 13, 2011, a user going by the name “ivan0135” uploaded a series of 4 videos purporting to show black and white clips of several longer films taken by the KGB between 1942 - 1969. The series of clips seem to show blurry antique footage, played on a projector, of a flying saucer over a rural farmhouse, a crashed spacecraft with a deceased alien, an alien autopsy, a living...

SKIP TO 00:17:32 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S EPISODE! Welcome to Episode 174: The Chemtrail Conspiracy! Today we will be discussing a conspiracy theory that has steadily taken foothold on social media in recent years: The Chemtrail Conspiracy. You know those white trails of clouds that airplanes leave behind as they fly? Well, this theory suggests that those trails are not made of water condensation, but are actually made of poisonous gases and biological agents used to keep our population sick,...

SKIP TO 00:09:51 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S EPISODE! Welcome to Episode 173: A Deep Dive into the Horrifying Rusalki of Slavic Folklore! Today we will be diving headfirst into the algae-filled ponds and rushing green rivers of the Rusalki, learning about their wants, needs, desires, history, and even - about some modern day sightings of them. What’s a Rusalka, you ask? A Rusalka is the Slavic equivalent of a mermaid, but usually depicted without a tail. She is beautiful, alluring, and above all -...

SKIP TO 00:11:37 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! On December 4th, 1872 an abandoned ship known to be cursed was found floating in the Atlantic Ocean. The ship appeared perfectly sound, possessed a full cargo, and even had enough provisions in the galley to sustain a crew for 6 months of sail... but what happened to her crew and captain? This week, Nat takes Aly across the Atlantic Ocean on a journey full of mystery and mayhem as she unravels the most confounding seafaring case from the Age of...

SKIP TO 00:13:00 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S EPISODE!   Welcome to Episode 171: Paranormal Games To Play In The Dark, Volume VI! Today, we continue with the fan-favorite series of supernatural games you can play by yourself…if you dare. On today’s series installment, Aly explains to Nat how to play two games that promise encounters with beings from the other side. In the first game, you will learn how to figure out who - or what - your guardian angel is. Do you even have one? Completing this game...

Welcome to Episode 170.5: Listener Stories #25! This is the episode where our Haunties (aka listeners) write in with their first-person spooky tales of cryptids, ghosts, curses, aliens, and more! Listener stories from this week’s episode include: a funeral ghost, a tarot reading from beyond, a crouched sleep demon that resembles the girl from The Ring, a grinch hand coming out of a closet, mirror portals, accidentally phasing into an alternate dimension for a year, shadow people with crow...

SKIP TO 00:10:50 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! Happy Valentines Day 2024 Haunties... or is it Valentines Day 1724? This week, Nat convinces Aly that our current calendar is a fake and history as we know it is a lie. According to the Phantom Time Conspiracy, the years known colloquially as "The Middle Ages" never even happened and we are all currently living in the 1720s. Even more disturbing, some of our most treasured heroes, artifacts, and historical events, are complete fabrications! WHAT?...

SKIP TO 00:20:00 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S EPISODE!   Welcome to the SEASON 6 PREMIERE - Episode 169: The Green Children of Woolpit! Sometime in the 12th Century in the English village of Woolpit, a farmer stumbled upon two orphaned children at the edge of his property. This in and of itself might not have been so strange, had it not been for the fact that both children were sporting completely green skin. The children spoke in a language no locals could understand, and said they came from a...

IMPORTANT! Don't forget to take the San 5 Listener Survey before the end of January! You can find it at our link tree (first link in the list): https://linktr.ee/letsgethaunted.  Welcome to the Season 5 Finale Q&A Episode, Haunties! Join Nat & Aly as they unbox fan mail, recap the season, and answer the questions that YOU submitted! LGH wishes everyone who has been a part of our 2023 a very happy holiday season and an even better New Year. We’ll see you all in February 2024 for the...

SKIP TO 00:14:42 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! It’s the largest airport in North America, and the second largest airport in the world; However, it’s the only airport with it’s very own conspiracy theory. There are talking gargoyles popping out of suitcases above the baggage claim, gigantic murals depicting world domination, secret codes etched in the floor, rumors of underground bunkers for the global elite, and even a demon horse with glowing red eyes known as “Bluecifer”! What exactly is...