The two couples pair off on their dates -- Chris and Anna enjoying dinner and dessert out while Lilith entertains Don at her new home. Eventually the conversations of each couple separately involve the same topic: Don's dreams of Lilith. When Lilith discovers Don's dreams, she is convinced that Don is the reincarnation of her first and true love 300 years ago, when she was still human. Yet when Anna hears Chris describe the dreams, she has the same realization. She confides this to Chris and then also drops the real bombshell: that Lilith is a vampire.