“Fascinating podcast.
I feel that Baddiel does his absolute best to understand Sayeeda’s views yet it’s not always reciprocated.
E.g. during latest pod about Gideon Falter I felt Baddiel was articulating brilliantly what a lot of us liberal-secular Jews feel - that how non-Jews feel about us should be independent of our views of Israel. But Sayeeda’s rationale that Falter is linked to settlements (by a chain of four) precludes him from being on the end of antisemitism demonstrates exactly the issue Baddiel is trying to point out.
As an atheist-Jew, I would love them to GO THERE about religion a bit more. And whether it should be analysed/criticised as a true-false or not.”
Toby Katz via Apple Podcasts ·
Great Britain ·
04/26/24