Description
India Policy Watch: Our Week With Adani
Insights on current policy issues in India
- RSJ
That was an eventful week in India. In the last edition I had written these lines on the ongoing Adani saga that have now come back to bite me:
“The FPO might struggle a bit to sail through. But that amount is a chump change for the group. A week or so of volatility, some questions from regulators, a few lawsuits, some strategically timed PR events and the group will be done with this kerfuffle by February. This is nothing more than a minor speed bump in its fortunes.”
Ooh. It didn’t turn out to be a minor kerfuffle. After the Adani Group came out with their 400+ page response to the Hindenburg report who then retorted with their characteristic bite, we witnessed a free fall in Adani stocks in the first few days of the week. The FPO barely saw any retail participation. A few anchor investors including an Abu Dhabi sovereign fund participated. And then at the eleventh hour we had family offices of prominent Indian industrial houses and few domestic institutional investors subscribe to it and the FPO just about sailed through. Social media was abuzz with either ‘see, this is the spirit of new India’ or ‘upar se call aaya hoga’ (they must have got a call from the top) kind of messages. But even this news didn’t mean much. The free fall continued that day. Eventually, the Group canceled the FPO and positioned itself as a martyr to the cause of investors who have stood by them over the years. Well, you live long and you get to see everything. There was further negative news for the group as the Dow Jones decided to remove Adani Enterprises, the flagship company of the group, from their sustainability index. A few global banks reported they wouldn’t accept Adani bonds as collaterals from their clients for margin trading. Only late on Friday, was there some good news coming in from the Group. They confirmed they kept their bond payout commitments and that all interest payments have been made till date. A couple of credit agencies, that prescient lot who you will remember didn’t have a clue till a day before the Lehman crisis that something was wrong, confirmed there’s no debt maturing among the group companies till 2025. Only then did the stocks find some respite.
So, you see not exactly what I had predicted. And so I’m somewhat less certain now if this will only just be a minor bump in the road for the group.
The other big event during the week was the Union budget that was presented on Feb 1. This was the last full budget to be presented before the 2024 general elections and there was an expectation that the government would tilt towards being more populist. Even here, I had made a prediction at the start of the year:
“..this government has always been careful about fiscal deficit, and it is particular about the risk of the fiscal space. The government has committed to a 4.5 per cent target for the union government deficit in the next 3 years from the current levels, that’s expected to be 6.4 per cent. I see a tightening in the fiscal stance during the year with a gradual reduction in some of the pandemic-related subsidies and better targeting of the benefits improving distribution efficiency."
Phew. On this I was right. The government cared more for its fiscal deficit trajectory than being populist. The surprising part, and the one I got wrong, was the significant capex push that is budgeted to grow 33 percent to Rs. 10 trillion in the coming year. Despite this, the government expects the deficit to be down to 5.9 percent in line with its three-year plan. How did it manage that? Well, forget populism, this government plans to cut down on subsidies and expenditures during a pre-election year. The subsidies budget is down 27 percent from Rs. 5.2 trillion to Rs. 3.7 trillion. At a macro level, this is an important message about its fiscal management philosophy. The infra push follows three themes that are all good
Prediction Time
—RSJ
In a year when countries as diverse as India, the United States, the United Kingdom, Russia, Taiwan, Pakistan and Palau go for their elections, it is tempting to go for an overarching theme for the year while looking ahead. Unfortunately, like these aforementioned elections...
Published 01/14/24
Happy New Year
— RSJ
Happy 2024, dear readers!
We hope 2023 was good for all of you. If it wasn’t, we are glad that it’s behind you. We didn’t have too bad a 2023 ourselves. This newsletter went along swimmingly (or so we think) and we had our book ‘Missing in Action: Why You Should Care About...
Published 01/07/24