Not for the casual historian
Dan Carlin attacks the subjects of his podcast with all the enthusiasm and bravado of a college freshman. He may state the context is king but that doesn’t mean he’s found the context. He makes it readily apparent that he is a journalist and not a historian by missing the fine details in favor of broad generalizations and assumptions based on a quick analysis of those generalizations. On top of that he desperately wants you to know that he is intelligent, often taking detours that have the soul purpose to demonstrate how well read and or smart he is. If nothing else this podcast will hopefully inspire people to research these topics themselves and learn the real history from a historian who has true a contextual understanding. Lastly if pronunciation matters to you he gets wrong almost every time sometimes to staggering degree adding or swapping vowels with reckless abandon.
Likes but... via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 06/11/24
More reviews of Dan Carlin's Hardcore History
I relish this podcast. I savor each episode and listen to it at only the most appropriate moments. I just finished the Scythian entry as I took a long bike ride on a dirt path through a scratchy, grassy sea. Dan has a way of evoking a sense of awe and dark mystery that spills over into our 21st...Read full review »
darwingodwin via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 06/13/07
Here is a look at history that knocks the dust off academia without losing the authority. Mr. Carlin has a broad understanding of history and an ability to look across centuries to find the strands that connect us to distant events. Provokative at times, yet he doesn't cross the line into...Read full review »
BillyBobDiddly via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 06/23/07
love this podcast ... I listen to a lot of podcasts and this one is my favorite. well produced, good reading, interesting subjects even the background music is at the perfect level. pleas make more of these and make them faster. O.
patzpatz via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 07/12/07
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.