“I enjoy this show, I really do and I don’t mean anything in a combative way but come on Pat. Can you read this in a light hearted tone 😅. The thing that makes me crazy and the reason I didn’t give the show 5 starts is that I feel like Pat is always casting shade at Rebecca. I haven’t listened to the whole back catalogue but every time they give there final arguments he likes to point out that Becca cheats and not once have I heard her go over. Let it go Pat.
Becca does a really good job of telling a spooky story at the beginning but Pat is so dismissive and I feel like the whole time Becca sounds apologetic for how spooky everything feels to her. Pat dismisses her evidence and his arguments don’t hold anymore water than the evidence. He likes to chalk everything up to coincidence. How many things have to line up perfectly for any coincidence? Any coincidence is super natural so thanks for strengthening the argument Pat. Or he says it’s environmental, and I like to hear what he thinks it could be but he also has no evidence to support his claims. “The window could have been open.” Yeah, maybe. The one where he said the door had to close really slow or super fast and angry… is there some scientific research on that? I listened to one episode with a guest that was more on Becca's side and she sounded more confident and then it showed in the polls! That’s the other thing, when Pat wins he wins but when Becca’s percentage is over half they tie?! Na, na. Also, don’t be so dismissive of people’s “feelings”. That’s what makes an experience what it is.
I’m obviously a believer and I really do enjoy the show but I had to give a little shade back to Pat.
XOXO”Read full review »
katydarling2 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/31/23
“Not only is this podcast interesting because I learn about the history of places, people and their experiences, but listening to Rebecca and Pat debate for and against these ghostly hauntings/supernatural phenomena is so entertaining! I definitely am #teamskeptic but sometimes enough coincidences...”Read full review »
1Section leader1 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
06/12/21