“Who knew what Gimlet's third podcast would be? If you'd listened to the credits of the company's early podcast episodes and heard that editing was done by This American Life personality Starlee Kine, you might have had a hunch. Her writing turns serious into hilarious, her voice is unforgettable, and as an investigative journalist Starlee is a standout. It's about time she threw her hat into the ring of this new Podcast Renaissance. No doubt Mystery Show shall be an aural bonanza of madcap capers, edge-of-your-earbuds suspense and utter hilarity. Thanks Gimlet.”Read full review »
morganfitzp via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/01/15
“I enjoy Gimlet’s other podcast shows. I looked forward to Mystery Show ever since I heard the trailer a few weeks ago. I just finished the first episode. I found it boring. I will give “Mystery Show” one more chance. If I find the next episode equally boring, then I am finished with this podcast...”Read full review »
Jonathan Woytek via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/23/15
“As a superfan of both Startup and Reply All, I was eagerly awaiting the launch of Gimlet’s third podcast. But I’m sad to say that I was disappointed by the first episode of Mystery Show. It maintains a few aspects of what makes their other podcasts great—narrative journalism, superb marketing...”Read full review »
Zac Koons via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/23/15