“Please bring back the show , it is my favorite podcast. I know some of the former hosts may not be able to return to do so ,so assemble another crew. With a massive back catalogue of South Park and two new specials there is a lot to discuss. Hope you all are well, and I look forward to hearing...”Read full review »
Sludge! via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
04/26/21
“I will never get tired of watching South Park and listening to people talk about it in such detail and with such passion is incredible. I enjoyed every minute (or hour) and I love hearing everyone’s thoughts and interpretation of the episodes. Can’t wait for the next season!!”
“It loses a star because Amanda adds nothing to the podcast. She seems like a joyless woman and never seems to like any episode. She doesn’t really add much either and just seems to fill the “woman” quota. I’d love to see her contribute something or have something to add but she doesn’t.”
Millenial Philosopher via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
01/20/20
“I give it 5 b/c I keep listening. It’s not perfect but it’s not supposed to be - a bunch of very different points of view discussing South Park. I don’t agree with everyone but that (should) be the point”
hootieman via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
12/08/19
“If you are reading this Amanda, I am sorry. You are just not cut out for podcast. I hate when you talk. Please step down from podcasting, South Park deserves it.”
Jon-O-pan via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
12/02/19
“To Jacob, if you disagree with your co hosts on why the episode is funny make your case don’t keep asking about their viewpoint because we already know what they’re gonna say. I already predicted lux and Amanda were give it a low grade because they do not like episodes that go against their...”Read full review »
SP_john via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/25/19
“This show should just be called “grown up, PC babies”. Would fit perfectly with the majority of woke, SJW, PC takes. Really not much analysis going on.”
Sscewd via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/16/19
“Subscribed as soon as the very first episode dropped. Insightful and entertaining.
Thanks to your There Will Be Blood recommendation last week, I’m now a Goo Man.”
“Always look forward to your breakdowns after each episode, gives a different perspesctive and way of looking at the message from the show. Keep up the great work”
very deep and insightful via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
10/11/19
“I’m a fan from Hong Kong, I was a fan for this podcast and South Park, but this episode really disappointed me. From the podcast I heard that everyone is like “Yeah! They nailed how things are in China! Great job!” just make me sad. As an international student here in the US I’ve always tried to...”Read full review »
煎Pan via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/06/19
“I really try to enjoy this podcast. And I look forward to hearing political debates regarding Parker and Stone’s commentary. But if you’re going to get political, at least be somewhat reasonable. Downplaying China as communist country then comparing their camps to the southern border in the same...”Read full review »
LamarIsElite8 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/04/19
“Basically, these episodes are usually great. However, at some point, not sure when, the podcast became more about how they would write it better. I'm not sure how they could possible feel they would do a better job, given that they are merely adopting the captain hindsight position when...”Read full review »
Jakob Skødt Nielsen via Apple Podcasts ·
Denmark ·
12/15/18
“Thanks for making these :) you make me look forward to my friday commute and your vids/podcasts make house chores a genuinely fun time. Im really excited to hear you have a video on Tolkien coming out, i cant wait. Also, do you think you will ever do a video on One Piece or The West Wing?
Your...”Read full review »
“A lot has been said about Amanda. She is terrible. The reason why she’s terrible is she’s exactly what the show is currently mocking with the Strong Women character, who she of course hates.
I understand why you want to include a women’s perspective on the show, but you couldn’t find someone...”Read full review »
drlcartman via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/30/18
“Amanda is just a horrible addition to the podcast. She provides no insight and just isn’t very good in the podcast in general, she just piggy backs on the ideas of others. My favorite episodes are before she arrived or whenever she missed a recording. The show is better off without her.”
TheDakASL via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/29/18
“I think this podcast is great, they may not say a bunch of things i agree with but that’s why I like it. Not sure why there is so much hate for Amanda. I disagree with Ryan most of the time and he’s on every Wisecrack podcast, having differing opinions is always a good thing. Love ya Amanda....”Read full review »
XCrisisX via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/16/18
“Just kidding, the amazingly review every South Park episode and if you are a big fan as me you will enjoy this podcast! It doesn't matter your South Park knowledge if you are a new fan, they make it easy for you. I started listening them when season 21 started and I still haven't watched...”Read full review »
“I’ve never written a review on anything but I don’t remember hearing anything for the other side on their stance for “The Problem with Apu” and it bothered me. I’ve heard other things that I didn’t really care to hear,but respected that we all have different opinions on things. But it leans too...”Read full review »
f1owo1f via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/25/18
“Show and YouTube series is amazing! I’ll keep watching on YouTube but can’t stand the podcast due to Amanda, “literally” fingernails on a chalkboard.”
100 starts via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/23/18
“If I could give this zero stars a I would. I could not think of a worse addition to the show than Amanda. She is a moron with a horrible voice, so much to the point that I had to stop listening to this show that I loved.”
Yummy Flavors via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/16/18
“Really like the Wisecrack crew and their other podcasts. I’ve been listening to ROA since it came out and have really enjoyed it. Unfortunately, Amanda has a way of really ruining the show. She seems to have a really negative attitude and her repetitive emphasis on the SHW horrors of DRUMPHS...”Read full review »
C-138 Dan via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/12/18
“I love wisecrack, and watch and listen to all the rest, but Amanda makes this impossible to enjoy. Her viewpoints are the stereotype of what's wrong with this country, she is whiney, and she literally doesn't understand the word literally. She is full of smug,smelling her own farts and...”Read full review »
Papabird73 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/12/18
“I feel like they’re so wrapped in nostalgia they don’t appreciate what’s happening now. They don’t seem to really like the show-or are just ultra critical to get ratings. Very few episodes can compare to the humour received from rewatching the same episode for ten years.”
Gcicero via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/08/18
“I really wanted to like this podcast but they just seems like old heads who don’t get it anymore. They have clearly grown out of South Park and it shows ever episode. Let it go guys.”
Nikki19894 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
09/28/18