No more gimmicks
Davidson seemed to bring some passion to this show early on, McKay felt busy promoting his (surprisingly awesome) movie. I would agree with reviews that noted the odd chemistry between Adams-something that adding new hosts only seemed to reaffirm. Topics were hit or miss, then the regular hosts faded out - maybe I missed the episode that explained where they went - and the producer Rachel Ward and whoever they could rope in to help her just couldn't pull it off. Gimlet does well when it creates shows that are a forum for the hosts (and producers/team I'd imagine) to explore what they love. We as listeners come to love it too and we build a real human connection with the show. When we are dragged through a trivia fest by unnaturally exuberant but (not personally engaged) hosts, we listeners hang out for a while, then depart. If you're tired of Surprises, try the work of another Gimlet producer who appears on Reply All: Sruthi PinnamaneniRead full review »
Natebyerley via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 01/08/17
More reviews of Surprisingly Awesome
Enjoyed the information & the surprise of how it became a fascinating subject!! Keep up the great work.
Notdrwatson88 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 11/05/15
I love interesting topics and many different facets to them. But this show takes the mundane most boring things and makes them superbly interesting. Can't wait for more episodes.Read full review »
Guitmasq via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 11/15/15
The hosts play up how 'fascinated' they are the whole time, but you can't fool me; Adam McKay's aunt and stories about concrete aren't any more interesting than they sound on face.Read full review »
PostUpLegend via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 11/19/15
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.