“I’d like to preface my review by saying that I write this from the perspective of a mental health therapist, a true crime aficionado, and, most importantly, as a human being. I’d also like to say that after listening to dozens of long form podcasts, this is the ONLY one that has moved me so...”Read full review »
Deaf Dani via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/16/24
“Listen to the whole series. It’s amazing how much my attitude changed at the very end towards the cop. Still don’t like him, but to hear the raw emotion and to have him see a completely unexpected reaction from someone he put away was so, just - wow.”
“Really interesting story and wonderful to have so many of the main characters speaking directly to their experience.
Unfortunately, for me, the production took away from the story. At times the sound effects and music, along with the drama in the hosts’ narrative felt misplaced. The story and...”Read full review »
Natski75 via Apple Podcasts ·
Australia ·
05/13/24
“I was with you all on this journey until your encounter with Jewell (sp). She didn’t owe YOU an explanation, and you could clearly see that she was in distress, but you persisted.
Disgusting.”
TonyaA6 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/09/24
“Average story of over zealous detective broken into WAY too many parts. First episode has the bold storytelling hook then falls asleep for the remainder. Seems more like a hit piece against the detective than a requiem on criminal justice as a whole.”
waxmygeorgewbush via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/07/24
“I’m excited to hear the stories that you found they touch me personally because I have experienced things like this. Keep up the good work sides of their stories love the theme song think it fits perfectly.”
TruecrimeKSUGREAT via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
04/29/24
“This is a complicated and important story told in a way that brings it to life. I felt like I knew the main characters by the time I finished. People need to understand that the serious failings of our justice system, at its worst, can literally steal a person’s life. It’s shallow to pick on the...”Read full review »
Mamabootycat via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
04/23/24
“Ok I get that this is free media and supported by ads, but the volume and frequency of ads ruin the listening experience. The show opens with a solid 2 mins of ads before it even gets going, then, 12 mins later you get blasted by another 3 min wall of ads. This show just isn’t worth it....”Read full review »
bung and bunger via Apple Podcasts ·
New Zealand ·
04/23/24
“As a wrongful conviction advocate I wasn’t sure about hearing Scarcella’s story. Happy to report I was totally wrong, I’m obsessed with this podcast. Steve Fishman is one of the finest journalists and the way he interviews Scarcella is masterful. Dax playing devils advocate and presenting...”Read full review »
Lis5718 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
04/17/24
“A good story with a terrible format. I hate when podcasters use their podcast to play DJ. Awful, unnecessary music. So slow to develop, 1st episode all you get is a stretched out introduction. 2/3’s of the way into episode 2 and you still do not know what’s going. They just drag out the story and...”Read full review »
ulyfv35 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
04/15/24
“Always looking for something to accompany long drive to work. Great story. Didn’t know where it was going. Kinda stunned by the ending. If you’re looking for a new binge listen, you found it.”
shaw davari via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
03/21/24