Review of The Rings of Power Wrap-up - Good For Those That Only

Good For Those That Only Like the Text

☆

“After listening to a few of the episodes including 10, these guys have a lot of knowledge and are clearly respected which is good, but be aware that they tend to take a jab at most elements that don’t line up with the text (even if there isn’t any relevant Second Age text). I feel that they look down their nose at adaptations, even elements of the ComicCon trailer, so for that reason I’ve become weary listening to the constant undercurrent of skepticism. If you only like the text, that’s fine, but I suggest that you just study the text and ignore the adaptations, and let others enjoy the adaptive trip back to Middle Earth.”

ElectExile66 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/08/22

More reviews of The Rings of Power Wrap-up

See all »

Great companion to the show

☆

“The hosts are just the right mix of knowledgeable, skeptical, and enjoyable. Best Tolkien show I’ve found yet!”

Alex Meteorologist via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 01/08/23

Excited to listen to this!

☆

“I love the Prancing Pony Podcast and I cannot wait to begin listening to this too. I happened to stumble upon the PPP a couple years ago when I attempted to read the Silmarillion. Alan and Shawn are excellent hosts and made my dive into the book so easy and enjoyable. I am slowly making my way...”Read full review »

wi11yam via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/12/22

Oh dear

☆

“The episode covering S2 Ep8 was somewhat embarrassing- listening to 3 adults having a hissy fit about criticism and making barbed comments like sulky teenagers throughout. Come on people - it’s not a good look. Shame, as the context and analysis of the show’s interpretation of the source material...”Read full review »

Murjim2 via Apple Podcasts · Great Britain · 10/05/24

Do you host a podcast?

Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.