Willing to give it a shot
I have no problem with the extremely thin premise of this show – Alex and PJ’s on-pod chemistry is one of great things about Reply All. I was glad, however, to learn that Jason Mantzoukas was only a special guest on this first episode and will not be on every episode. I know that they are big fans of his, but I just do not find him at all funny, nor does he ever have any expertise or interesting perspectives to add. He honestly seems like the kind of guy who likes to hear himself talk; every sentence is a mansplain. Nothing personal, Mr. Mantzoukas, I am sure you are a fine fellow.
LadyGrady via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 05/05/20
More reviews of The Scaredy Cats Horror Show
I really enjoyed this first ep, bc I’m the same way - I read horror movie scripts and Wikipedia pages bc I’m too scared to watch them. The people leaving one star reviews because the name is similar to another name seem petty - I guess none have listened and they are just angry about the...Read full review »
Matt J Price via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 04/30/20
I love Reply All and I love horror movies so this is immediately one of my favorite podcasts! Don’t chicken out P.J., there’s not enough new Reply All to feed my P.J. and Alex fix! Here’s some of my favorite not super scary horror movies as suggestions: Re-animator, Evil Dead 2, Slither, Dead...Read full review »
jaceonoata via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 05/01/20
The podcast itself is competent, it's just a shame that Gimlet have either failied to check for anything already using the name, or they simply don't care. Bad look for them either way. Pick a unique name and stop knocking off Thought Slime's youtube channel!Read full review »
DJNWDJNW via Apple Podcasts · Great Britain · 04/30/20
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.