“This podcast is ideally titled. It is all about excuses NOT to write. Talk about tv, watch tv, absolutely. Teach people how to be hacks? This show does it in spades. Learn about the massive talents of Brandon. Listen to Mary associate literature to puppetry. (That is the same as comparing superhero comics to literature. Shallow value.) Get a thesaurus of pet jargon from Howard and insights gleaned from a life in front of the television set.
They have value as a parody of good writers. By instructing others how to be formulaic hacks they are helping to reduce their own shelf life even further.
As a writing professor I am thoroughly entertained by a podcast about writing that talks so little about writing and reading. With the exception of Mary's occasional references to Jane Austin or King Lear, any writing advice this group gives is based on a MOVIE they saw. Any discussion of character developmental involves Star Wars characters or the latest interpretation of dwarves. The show makes me laugh because the only literature they examine is each others'. E.B. White (look him up!) once wrote that the people with the least sense of humor spend hours examining it. Howard of Writing Excuses is exhibit A. I am bashing you folks because you have created a good forum here but you are doing so little to develop yourselves as writers. The only conflicts humans have are those that threaten the fabric of the universe? Really? Take some of your own homework seriously. Grow.
But it is most off base at its core. Good writing is not a fifteen minute, hurried exercise because "we are in a hurry". All good writing requires time and the hosts talk like they do not have a clue about that. Instead they rattle off their jargon, advise people to go LISTEN to a story, and say goodbye just as the conversation has a chance of having something substantial to offer.
These folks gave me a new synonymn for bad writing- EPIC FANTASY.”Read full review »
storyteller/educator via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
12/05/16
“This podcast is invaluable if you have a passion for writing, and entertaining even if you’re not interested in the subject (my sister for example is a reader not a writer and she loves it). The gang are so hilarious and each episode is filled with concise, lively discussion of stories and how to...”Read full review »
ArchersFan via Apple Podcasts ·
Great Britain ·
11/11/17
“I have listened to all available podcasts of this show on ITunes. I have listened to some episodes more than once. Fantasy is by far my favorite genre and Brandon has fast become my hero, and favorite author. Dan Wells I loved John Cleaver 1. Mary I can't wait to read some of your...”Read full review »
khozii via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/21/16
“Each episode is intriguing and packed with useful information. l’m currently about 30 episodes in, and not only am l picking up a ton of writing tips, l’m thoroughly enjoying the process! l’m a podcast junkie and a critical consumer, so l don’t speak lightly when l say this podcast series is one...”Read full review »
DefinitelyNotStripeS via Apple Podcasts ·
Canada ·
08/27/18
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.