“As a new fan to the ASOIAF universe, looking for creators that put out content that’s not hard to understand and that is really intriguing can be pretty overwhelming. There’s hundreds of creators to choose from but Preston and Carmine are up their in my Go-To’s. Recently I finished the show for...”Read full review »
Kev_Snow via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
09/09/24
“So the GoT podcast w/Preston Jacobs is in fact not a podcast with Preston Jacobs.
Cool title, bro.
What a waste of time listening to two dudes claiming to like a thing and then explaining why the thing is actually bad. Unbelievable.
5 stars for Preston only.”
Oryx700 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
06/20/24
“I love Carmine and Preston. They’re like a classic Virgo/Capricorn power couple. Preston dots the I’s and Carmine ignores the T’s so they don’t lose our attention and I can listen for 3 hours straight.
The knowledge of sigils and story is what I’m here for, but they are relatable because they...”Read full review »
reallydopeand via Apple Podcasts ·
Australia ·
09/25/22
“Quite pretentious discourse with the knowledge to back it up. An ASOIF snob’s (like me) dream. The dynamic takes some listens to get used to; Carmine might be some A.I. that Preston created to seem more relatable. But who knows! Excellent deep dives regardless!”
DiscoveryDog via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
04/26/22
“Not sure what to make of the theories, from a man claiming he’s probably wrong about half of it. Cool Podcast dudes, thanks for keeping ASOIAF going while few books have been out.
I enjoyed the dorne podcast, and wouldnt mind hearing the other theories discussed on this platform either.
And...”Read full review »
Y van Dijk via Apple Podcasts ·
Netherlands ·
01/11/21
“Well thought out, candid and always an enjoyable listen. Carmine and Preston have great chemistry. Covering a broad range of topics, this podcast never misses the mark. Served with ample doses of humor and sarcasm, no matter which show they are covering, this podcast is inevitably more...”Read full review »
John in Kentucky via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/26/20
“...but please stop putting everything behind a paywall.
Edit: 2 Star -> 5 Star I havent seen a “teaser” podcast in a while now. Plus I just enjoy listening to them”
Solomon Rivers via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/17/20
“That guy has potential but I think he has to grow more as a person. I don’t know, maybe travel the world or read more. He just seems very easily lead. Like he would refuse to wear a mask because Joe Rogan said so.
Idk, it just sounds like Preston is taking it easy on this guy because they have...”Read full review »
St Nickname via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
07/30/20
“Always entertaining to listen to! Found both on youtube and since they teamed up nothing better. Reading through Fire & Blood currently and the insight these two put in, next level!”
f.rolf via Apple Podcasts ·
Switzerland ·
11/13/19
“Carmine and Preston make a good team. Carmine’s brash candor and humor (baba booey baba booey!) mixed with Preston’s practical yet detailed analysis gives the audience a natural feeling of conversational and thorough reviews of GoT, etc.
Just a question — are either of you into Twin Peaks?...”Read full review »
MBDALBEY via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
10/29/19
“Always enjoyable to hear your voices, I am happy to see that you’re gonna be continuing with new topics and am overjoyed to hear redteamreview getting slowly deprogrammed by Preston.”
ghoulish-smee via Apple Podcasts ·
Great Britain ·
10/26/19
“As a physican and master of pubic health (MPH), I can state without reservation that Carmine and Preston will incite healthy laughter and cerebral stimulation to your day/week. Philosophical, psychological, literary, and sociologic discussions in a relatable fashion seasoned with humor, they...”Read full review »
Linn Carol via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
06/03/19
“It’s a great podcast. Preston is intelligent and insightful while Carmine is just the average guy with a teenager sense of humor but they know there stuff when it comes to topics. I truly hope they work together. Like I said in the title, these two personalities are so different but they...”Read full review »
adhlx via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
05/21/19
“Two of my favourite youtubers come together to chat about ASOIAF! Carmine does a great job of hosting and Preston has so much knowledge of the books and the wider Thousand World universe”
Callum Paris via Apple Podcasts ·
Great Britain ·
05/11/19
“I like these guys, though I appreciate Preston far better for his knowledge on the subject. He is very good at relating ASOIAF with Martin’s other works and historical events that may have influenced the text as well.
Carmine is just there to asks questions and keep Preston on track and avoid...”Read full review »
VKing4444 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
04/21/19
“Preston is a gift to those that appreciate deep dives and critical (not cynical) analysis. For a guy that works at the State Dept he would sure make a great historian, literary critic or fiction professor. But instead we get to enjoy his insight for free. Note: Hosted by Carmine.”
milehighmassive via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
04/03/19
“Very entertaining and insightful pocast series. Can't get enough of it and highly recommend it to anyone interested in 'A Song of Ice and Fire' and\or the TV-show. (Might be more enjoyable if if you're not a particularly big fan of season 5 onwards...:)).”Read full review »
Keilfleckbaerbling via Apple Podcasts ·
Switzerland ·
03/01/19
“As a three-year listener to “Rereading Ice,” “1000 Worlds Book Club” etc., it’s with mixed emotions that I enjoy these podcasts. They’re very entertaining, but Carmine’s youth, ignorance of other GRRM works and his obvious discomfort whenever Preston brings up ANYTHING related to sex, made the...”Read full review »
Mr. Backwards C via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
12/19/18
“Both Carmine and Preston are an excellent duo when talking all things Thrones. They both provide excellent insight and opinions the Game of Thrones universe. There podcast provides excellent in depth discussions on show decisions, book analysis, and fan theories. It truly is an excellent...”Read full review »
jmach03 via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/29/18