Inspired by the movie Scream, two 16-year-old Pocatello High School students began a documentary about killing their classmates. Brian and Torey were obsessed with horror movies, serial killers, and death. By their Junior year, they were ready to make their fantasy a reality by targeting their friend Cassie, a straight-A student, artist, and athlete. Moments before murdering her, they dressed in masks, knocked things around the basement, and cut the power in true, theatrical horror. What followed would get them tried as adults for murder and land them life sentences in prison. Nearly 20 years later, many argue over whether they truly regret their actions.