The Catholic Church was quick to intervene in the murder of one of their own— Sister Margaret Ann Pahl. The suspect, also one of their own, Father Gerald Robinson, was a beloved man of the cloth. When his personal letter opener matched the wounds of Sister Margaret, the local Monsignor discreetly shut the investigation down. Two decades later, an anonymous letter detailing years of horrific abuse within the church put the spotlight back on Father Robinson. A new set of eyes on the case quickly reconnected the dots.