“I enjoy the informative banter of the two hosts, Lance and Tim. Their interest in the story is genuine, and their continued efforts to present the facts and correct their previous mistakes are appreciated.
However, I cannot listen to this podcast anymore until focus is removed from James Renner. This attention-hungry blogger has injected himself permanently into the case and intends to stay there, in the middle of the action, no matter the cost. Segments with Renner come across as both pathetic and delusional. He has obviously identified Maura Murray's case as the path to his 15 minutes of fame, sank his teeth in, and refuses to let go.
I had to turn off the most recent episode because Renner, guest hosting for the second time in nearly as many episodes, would not stop talking about his own blog. He is clearly more interested in himself and his trolls than the investigation. Renner is a distraction from the case and a detriment to the show.
Two stars for the podcast when Renner is not a factor. I will reconsider my review and possibly resubscribe if the hosts decide to stop taking him seriously. Until then, I will get my information elsewhere.”Read full review »
mysterystuffCM via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
09/16/15
“This used to be a great podcast. Driven, ambitious to uncover information, and bring that information to the listeners in an exciting and thrilling way. It was great!
Unfortunately, it's strayed a long way off course... It seems like the writers prefer talking about themselves more so than...”Read full review »
cait.porter via Apple Podcasts ·
Australia ·
11/17/15
“Seemed to me they started with good intentions, but were in way over their heads and now stumble aimlessly. At times, it sounds like an honest attempt to find the truths of the case; others, it's just one more forum to vent every crazy (and sometimes offensive/irresponsible) theory. The...”Read full review »
carolimelux via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
12/12/15
“This true crime pod started strong with the first 3 episodes telling the story of a mysterious disappearance. It has since devolved into substanceless paranoid ramblings. It's become more about the casters and not at all about the missing Maura. Afraid I'm going to let this one go.”Read full review »
Jennimay via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
11/26/15
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.