18 - Karen talks about the true story behind the movie Alpha Dog, a senseless crime that unfolded from one bad decision after another. Becky shares new information about the unsolved case of Kristin Smart. Kate dives into the heartbreaking story of missing kids Tylee Ryan and JJ Vallow, along...

Episode 17 - Becky discusses the creepy but true story of the Slender Man stabbing. Kate talks about a walking tour she recommends for anyone visiting New York or St. Augustine. Karen shares the story of a REAL LIFE, not fictional,  treasure hunt that is still going on today (can you tell who...

16 - Mr. Stanford on the front porch with the machete - that’s the conclusion we all come to when Kate talks about the unsolved gruesome murder of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley. Becky discusses the murder of Laci Peterson, where again, we all agree that the case is closed. Karen shares a personal...