“I’ve been listening to this podcast so long (from the beginning, I’m pretty sure—2008? 2009?) I almost feel like Steve, Dana, and Julia are my friends inside my phone. I read Slate and had massive media crushes on Steve and Dana way before the podcast. Julia is smart too. But... lately their topics are losing me, and it’s partly me and partly them. For several years Julia, as editor in chief of Slate, had disproportionate influence on their choice of topics. Either because her husband’s in TV or driven by poptimist tendencies which I don’t share, she’s steered the discussion overwhelmingly toward TV and other streaming, which I don’t watch and don’t care about (and yes, I’ve moved farther in that direction over the past decade, and yes, I may be out of touch). It hasn’t gotten any better since she switched to being managing something something for the LA Times. What I live for, and what has become vanishingly rare, are Steve’s blistering takes of old on cultural trends, sometimes veering into politics, always informed by a solid sense of history. I tune in every week hoping to recapture the magic (maybe even a discussion of a book? that’s not on HBO??) only to forward through most of it as irrelevant. I kind of wish Steve and maybe Dana could (have the time and resources to) break away and start their own podcast—not because I don’t appreciate Julia’s opinions when it’s not about TV, but only because that is so frustratingly rare. I’m not giving up on you, Culturefest, but don’t give up on me, ok?”
Florafloraflora via Apple Podcasts ·
United States of America ·
07/17/20