The Oatmeal Killer - Carmel, Indiana
Listen now
This week, in Carmel, Indiana, a custody battle between exes turns dangerous, when one starts asking around, about any hitmen that can help out. When none seem to be available, the whole thing turns into a ridiculous comedy of of errors, involving the killer's children, and other exes, before this person finally succeeds with the murder, using some of the strangest weapons that we've heard of... oatmeal, a neck tie, and fentanyl. Along the way, we find out that Greeks use unmelting cheese, that you usually don't reheat oatmeal, and that you shouldn't try to enlist everyone you've ever met, in your murder plot!! Hosted by James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman New episodes every Thursday! Donate at: or go to and use our email: [email protected] Go to for all things Small Town Murder & Crime In Sports! Follow us on... Also, check out James & Jimmie's other show, Crime In Sports! On Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, Wondery, Wondery+, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to podcasts! See Privacy Policy at and California Privacy Notice at
More Episodes
This week, in Horn Lake, Mississippi, the neighborhood is woken up by a series of explosions, in a house. The fire causes the terrible & painful death of a woman. It's ruled an accident, but some investigation reveals a sinister plot, from the most trusted person in the victim's life. From...
Published 05/23/24
Published 05/23/24
This week, in Summerville, South Carolina, two women meet in rehab, and one invites the other to live at her house, rent free. This new tenant has a cray past, and present, because she is a meth smoking, pill popping, booze swilling maniac, with an estranged husband, living behind a Wal Mart....
Published 05/17/24