We don’t need keyboard clicks!
It’s great storytelling but I have to say it - it’s 2024 we don’t need keyboard clicks and twitter whistles to understand that the voice is reading a text/tweet, especially when the narrator literally says it’s a tweet. It’s so distracting and annoying! It’s making it incredibly difficult to listen to the podcast. PSA for all podcasters: PLEASE don’t add that in. We don’t need it. We are smart enough to follow along without the sound effect. As far as content, I agree with many other reviews that it feels overly drawn out. Interviews come across more like small-town trash talk and gossip rather than telling the story of what happened. Audio quality is disappointing with the interviews as well. It’s a compelling story but I’ve heard many other retellings that are far more interesting. There is so much focus on Rachel and Sheila that you almost completely forget about Skylar. I know they’re being portrayed has high school mean girls but all the interviews and even the narrator commentary feels like more means girl talking about other mean girls.
Cross My Heart via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 04/29/24
More reviews of Three
Love this and I love that you’re covering a case from WV, we have a lot of cold cases that do not get the publicity they should (I know this is not a cold case). I appreciate the fact you took this on, and are putting WV on the map and people will know us as a small state and not Western...Read full review »
Air_ren via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/13/24
Definitely worth listening to, eeven if you are familiar with this sad story. Good job!
KC Idaho via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 03/03/24
I edited the magazine story by Holly Millea that this podcast is based on. It was the most-read piece in ELLE at the time. Keep listening! Holly and Justine have unearthed new facts and insights into this terrible, fascinating case. A story older than time—three’s a crowd—with a 21st century...Read full review »
liesled via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 02/19/24
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.
See hourly chart positions and more than 30 days of history.
Get Chartable Analytics »