Have you heard of The Winged Ones?!? These mysterious humanoid creatures with wings have been known to startle people near Lake Michigan and throughout Northern California with their red eyes and swift movement. On this week’s episode, Anthony tells three stories of Winged encounters and his guests, Andrew Heinlein, Christopher Mennella, and Ryan McCauley must decide which two stories are true and which one is the lie! Join them as they dissect the myths and play a fun mini-game of Never Have...

Do you believe in Aliens? This week, long awaited guest host, Ryan McCauley, presents Anthony Mennella, Tom Heinlein, Christopher Mennella with three distinct tales of alien encounters and together they must decipher which two are true myths and which one is the lie! From meeting an alien who stands 7 feet tall to holding an alien at gunpoint, this week's myths bring no shortage of spookiness. Listen along with them and tune in as they play a mini-game where they put past podcast characters...

This week Anthony orchestrates the episode with fan submitted stories! From fleeing a humanoid, to getting a thumb chomped off, to seeing a man in a window at your Aunt's house, Anthony's guests must decipher which stories are myths and which one is the lie! Tune in to play along as they dissect each story and join them for a Mad Libs mini game. Start living a happier life today! Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your...

Do you believe in werewolves? According to legends, werewolves are people who morph into vicious, powerful wolves that are bloodthirsty beasts who cannot control their lust for killing people and animals. Back in the 1500's werewolves were popularly believed to be real. This week Anthony is joined by the Colon siblings who must decipher which of the two werewolf horror stories are real accounts from the 1500's and which one is a complete lie! Tune in to solve the mystery and play along as...

According to Algonquin legends, the wendigo haunts the northern forests of the United States and Canada, always looking for people to eat. In this week's episode, Anthony shares 3 stories of Wendigo encounters and his guests, Ryan McCauley and Christopher Mennella, must decipher which story is a lie. From pentagrams of salt in mysterious caves to hunting for goats to a chance encounter on a neighborhood cul de sac, Wendigos seemed to be getting spotted all over the place. Tune in to try and...

We take a break from scary stories this week and lean into comedy as Anthony shares three stories of a Florida Man getting up to no good. From replacing a car tire with a bicycle tire, RKO wrestling a $3700 plastic alligator, and throwing a car into a family's home, Anthony's guests must guess which story is a LIE! Tune in for all the drama and a fun True or False mini game!! Cut your wireless bill to 15 bucks a month at MintMobile.com/culter. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your...

Do you believe dolls can be haunted or is everyone just making stuff up? This week on True Myths, One Lie, Anthony and his buddies dissect three stories of creepy dolls. From a couples encounter with a doll who was on a first name basis with them at a museum, to an eBay doll that can't stop turning around, to a haunted doll that can't stop hopping into bed with their owner, the team guesses which stories are true and which one is the lie. This podcast is sponsored by BetterHelp and listeners...

You know that one friend you had growing up that would always use you as their personal chauffeur? Well sometimes those friends grow up to be the guest host of True Myths, One Lie! This week join guest host, Austin Murphy, and his friends Tom Heinlein and Larry Mennella as they listen to 3 stories and try to decipher which two are true and which ones the lie! Tune in for all the fun and a surprise mini-game of Guess Who Superhero Edition. Download Best Fiends FREE today on the App Store or...

Have you ever wondered what the creepiest content security cameras have captured is? Beyond the more humorous footage of someone picking their nose or fixing their wedgie, there’s the straight up scary, arguably supernatural footage that's bound to startle whoever is watching. This week, Anthony and his buddies hear three stories involving some spooky footage captured on camera. Get 10% your first month of BetterHelp by going to BetterHelp.com/Cutler35. Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send...

Have you ever been somewhere that just feels "off"? You might've accidentally stumbled into a backroom, a creepy room in a different reality than our own that you can unknowingly glitch into, and which can house a terrifying creature. This week, Anthony and gang hear three stories involving people "no clipping" into mysterious, otherworldly rooms that seemed like there was no exit. Plus, the guys play a choose your own adventure game where they try to escape their own backroom. And with the...

Picture a house, not creepy on its own, right? Well, put that same house in the woods and the creepy factor goes way up. This week, Culter35 and crew listen to 3 stories involving mysterious homes surrounded by trees and involve some type of paranormal activity. Scary phone calls, and creatures stalking people, so much more. One of the stories Anthony made up, can you discern fact from fiction? Plus, the guys play "Would You Rather?," with both choices involve being scared the whole time. Get...

Have you ever wondered what you'll be like in the future? According to these stories, it's entirely possible. This week, the Mennella brothers read through 3 stories regarding people time traveling or crossing timelines and interacting with their younger selves. Can you figure out which of the three is made up (without skipping ahead) or are you in a timeline where you guess wrong? Plus, Anthony and Christopher make up a brand-new science fiction story using 3 random words: Toad from Mario,...

It's the start of the new year, but it's time to look back at some of the most popular episodes from 2021! You loved stories about Aliens, Black-eyed Children, and Dogmen, so Anthony is bringing you 3 new stories, one each of the top 3 from last years. But even though we've got 12 new months of ahead of us, some things never change. One of the 3 stories was totally made up, so hopefully one of your New Year's Resolutions involved getting better at figuring out which story is a lie. Plus, the...

In a twist on the format, this week, Anthony gets in on the action. Bob McLaughlin, who is the father to popular YouTubers Jillian and Addie, sent in 3 absolutely insane childhood stories, one of which is not true. No one on the episode, including Culter35, know which story is the lie. The stories include paranormal encounters and running into super shady characters. Can you guess which one Bob made up? Plus, in another Bob-inspired mini-games called "Bob's Jobs," where Bob also submitted...

Elves are usually associated with Santa and Christmas, but I don't think these stories will fill you with the same holiday glee. This week, the guys discuss 3 elf sighting stories that are less festive and more terrifying. These evil elves aren't bringing Christmas gifts as much as horror and pain. One of the 3 stories is a lie, can you guess which one? Plus, despite everyone's complaints, Anthony and crew play a round of "Guess Who" where the guests try to guess the correct mythical creature...

We all love jolly ole Santa Claus, the chubby red-suited hero who brings us presents ever year on Christmas. Well, the guy we're talking about today ain't him. Krampus is an Eastern European legend that will haunt your holiday nightmares. This week, Culter and crew discuss 3 stories of run-ins with the giant horned demon-like creature, just in time for the holiday season. So which one of the three is NOT Krampus canon? Tune in to find out! Take advantage of SimpliSafe’s Holiday deals and get...

Also known as "The Weeping Woman" or "The Wailer", La Llorona is a Latin American folklore legend who allegedly drowned her children who can be summoned in the mirror. There are many stories of encounters with her, and you're about to hear 3 of them, plus a bonus story of a personal encounter. told by one of the guests. Story 1: A girl plays by a river near sunset when she hears a woman crying. She approaches the crying woman wearing all white, so she runs away. She feels a cold hand on her...

This week, Anthony and gang discuss 3 stories involving a crybaby bridge, which is some type of legend surrounding a bridge where a baby or child has died, often at the hands of their own mother, and has now cursed the bridge to be forever haunted. So which of the following 3 stories is less than true? Listen to find out! Story 1: A murderous cult threw a baby off of a bridge around the time that it was being constructed. One woman contends that while she and her friend were crossing the...

On a very special episode, Culter reads three creepy stories that were submitted by YOU, including one that supplies the lie of the episode. Listen to the supernatural experiences of other TMOL fans and find out which one among you is a liar! Story 1 from Abbie Meyer: A group of friends are playing on a playground when they decide to venture to the creepy rusty door leading into the school that has always intrigued them. When they enter, they see a doll on the floor being approached by a...

Welcome back! This week, Anthony reads the final 3 of 6 Skinwalker Ranch stories to truly challenge the guests to choose the lie out of more stories than ever before. And to hear part 1, check out las week's episode here!: https://bit.ly/TMOLEp28 Story 4: Tom, the owner of the ranch, check on their cattle and find that a calf was completely mutilated, but no blood anywhere. A few nights later, their dogs are barking at nothing, so Tom goes to investigate and sees two strange glowing orbs...

In the first of 2 parts, Anthony and guests hear 6 stories surrounding the infamous Skinwalker Ranch, a large plot of land in Utah where tons of paranormal events have occurred, even piquing the interest of the U.S. government. Story 1: A man is tending to his cattle when he spots a wolf, but upon closer inspection, they realize it's about 3 times the size of a normal wolf. The wolf attacks one of his cattle, prompting the man to shoot the wolf multiple times, barely fazing it. It finally...

This week, guest host Tom Heinlein presents 3 insane stories from his days as a delivery driver, two of which really happened to him and one is completely made up. Listen as the guests (including host Culter35) try to separate fact from fiction. Story 1: Tom spots robbers snatch a register from a Subway sandwich shop and ride off in a bike. Tom is approached by an investigator to hear what happened. Later it's revealed that the robbers were caught by following the loose change spilling from...

True Myths One Lie presents an exclusive preview of a brand new podcast movie from C13Features called "Treat" starring Kiernan Shipka. Welcome to Treat, a brand new thrilling and frightening podcast movie listening experience from C13Features. In Treat, Kiernan Shipka stars as Allie West, an unpopular teenager who is dealing with issues beyond her years while struggling to fit in with her seemingly perfect small town. But, on one Halloween night, everything changes, and she discovers that her...

Since we're in spooky season, it's only appropriate that this week, Anthony brings you 3 scary legends surrounding October 31st, better known as Halloween. One legend was made up (or just started today?) by Culter 35, can you put aside your fears to figure out which one it is? Story 1: A husband and wife are vacationing when they spot a Halloween party. The woman wants to go, the man does not and an argument ensues. When they return to the hotel room, the man snaps and brutally murders his...

It's part moth, it's part man, Mothman. This week, Anthony and crew hear 3 stories about the Southern urban legend who differs from other cryptids in that people believe it is a benevolent creature. Can you figure out which one is the lie before the end of the episode? Story 1: A woman is suddenly drawn to her window, where she encounters the Mothman creature. Even though she's terrified, she feels a strange comfort and she begins sensing something from him. A few weeks later, there is a...