Ever since we started this podcast this past summer, this is a case that has come up between the 4 of us on multiple occasions and split straight down the middle on whether or not Scott Peterson was rightfully convicted for the murder of his wife Laci. The Petersons looked to be the perfect all-American young couple doing very well for themselves in Modesto, California in 2002. On Christmas Eve, though, everything would turn upside down when Laci, nearly 8 months pregnant with the couple's first child, was reported missing. The case would immediately grip not just the community, but the world over in a matter of just a few short days as massive volunteer and search efforts would be launched in an attempt to bring Laci and her unborn child home to their family.