Reviews
An iconic podcast for an iconic show! The dynamic between the producers and Scott make me LOL. Watching the show along with the podcast makes me realize how incredible the show is and how crafty, creative and witty it truly is. I am so impressed with the cast of Gilmore girls and the podcast!
bride 22 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 10/02/22
Scott seems to have some views (gender norms, pushing kids academically, Ivy League = good) which I don’t think should be uncritically spread and the other hosts never check him on anything or disagree with him. Also this podcast is more ad than content. Makes me angry to have to hear the same ad...Read full review »
sina473 via Apple Podcasts · Germany · 09/26/22
Amy makes it extremely difficult to love the show. I am just now starting season 2 and episode 1 just confirms how horrible Amy is. She is so rude to Riley it’s insane. I read that Riley left? Not sure if it’s true but I totally understand why if she did. I love Scott he’s great, I love all the...Read full review »
itsveedarling via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/25/22
I just love the humor, the fun and the smiles this podcast bring me, and have from the start. Scott truly brings such a great perspective, and the unique aspect of this being his first time to watch the show makes it so fun, like seeing it with fresh eyes. All the girls are fun to listen to and I...Read full review »
cdbreaux via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/22/22
This podcast/idea has so much potential; however, Amy’s constant interrupting, rudeness, and tangents make it impossible to listen to. Countless people have said/are saying this, but no one who can help change this seems to care. I had to stop listening because it too obnoxious and exhausting.
olyfunmilayo via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/20/22
Love this podcast, love hearing behind the scenes, love hearing interviews with cast members & other crew members! Love the rapid fire questions, the pop culture references, the favorite lines of the episode and also the summary(but i wish the summary was given every single episode at the...Read full review »
Lyssie95 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/14/22
Can’t listen anymore because of Amy. I wish she would let other people talk and finish their thought processes.
hefkfksneicog via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/12/22
This podcast is my happy place. I have been obsessed with Gilmore Girls for many, many years [my daughter’s name is Rori - top that my fellow Gilmore Girls fans!] and have watched it bunches of times, like so many others here. I could never really get into podcasts, but I came across this podcast...Read full review »
Karis333 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/11/22
If you thought you loved Gilmore Girls before, this rewatch podcast will make you think you only kinda liked it before. This Podcast is Funny, nostalgic and just absolutely amazing! I loved Gilmore Girls before but I love it even more now!
Lulu52880 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/09/22
I’ve tried really hard to make it through this podcast but Amy makes it so hard to listen to…and obviously I’m not alone in that opinion - read your reviews! I LOVE Gilmore girls and I love all the background knowledge but she really isn’t needed and takes away from the charm.
HDG31 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/08/22
Danielle, Scott, and Riley are all great and entertaining and fun to listen to. But Amy is extremely rude and condescending to Riley, and I don’t understand why. It’s like she’s trying to be funny, but she just comes off as a bully picking on Riley any chance she can get. It’s also really...Read full review »
OULAWJRW via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/08/22
Amy is the living worst. Aside from her annoying voice, the others are ignorant. Scott is like an old uncle who you wish remembered anything about things but he can’t but once it’s about him that changes. This show has so much importance and meaning that is missed by this re watch. Watched this...Read full review »
dwightschrude via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/03/22
Love the podcast it makes me laugh
utlakergirl84 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/02/22
What I CANNOT deal with is Scott saying our Lord’s name in vain every 5 minutes. Either stop or bleep it out like you do with curse words that are far less offensive than hearing our Lord’s name used as a derogatory expression. Would you yell out “Allah” as a curse word? No. You’d be demolished....Read full review »
ilovemusic9 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 09/02/22
Love Amy! Love Scott! I wish I could do pop culture for you! Has anyone discussed that the actresses who play Miss Patty and Babbette were on All in the Family together?
denise.franklin via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/31/22
I know he doesn’t come into the show until season 5 but I’m so glad we got this interview. Great job Scott!
tarasoud via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/31/22
I really REALLY wanted to like this podcast but it’s more irritating than enjoyable. I just started listening to Gilmore Guys and am shocked to realize how many things were taken from that podcast for this one. I had to double check the dates to make sure I wasn’t assumptions, but Gilmore guys is...Read full review »
Paloma on the rocks via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/30/22
Scott is good so far but the other “host” is on my nerves. She’s so loud and cuts in and is a but too eager and excited. She does offer anything to the podcast, let scott do the talking
Kay122* via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/30/22
Seriously. Stop interrupting. It’s not your podcast. Amy needs to let others talk.
Crichblun via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/29/22
I like to hear Scott’s take on things and Tara & Danielle’s comments too. But Amy is (STILL) CONSTANTLY chattering, jumping in, cutting off anyone’s thoughts when they just start to express them!! “Can I just say something really quick?!!” (not quick, and several times throughout.) This...Read full review »
You'reTheVoice via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/29/22
I really, Really, REALLY wanted to like this podcast. I was super excited about pop culture and hearing about the episodes from someone who was there. However, all of that has failed. Scott gives nothing more that a white male privilege perspective, he proved this last episode without a doubt....Read full review »
pleaselisten1 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/28/22
Y’all immediately start talking about a scene and your opinions without even letting us know what scene it is. “What about when Emily did this?” We have to guess what part you’re even speaking about and then it’s something that was later in the episode when the podcast is at the beginning. Most...Read full review »
bclark334 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/26/22
Trying this podcast again for the third time. They have made improvements. Scott is doing so much better. Now if Amy would stop repeating the same points over and over until the others must agree to move on. In a very eventful episode like Keg Max spending over 10 minutes on scene with Max and...Read full review »
jessiejgirl89 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/25/22
I really wanted to love this. To be honest, I did love most of the first season of the podcast. Season 2 was a little shakey and I feel like it derailed after all the hosts returned after the Christmas break and coincidentally all had covid. I made it to S2-E14 "it should have been...Read full review »
Aly5587 via Apple Podcasts · Canada · 08/25/22
You guys are so very wrong about Richard. If you ever grew up with a dad like him you would understand that Richard did it EXTREMELY WRONG. If my dad had approached my kids before he asked my permission first he would never see my kids again. The idea is great and right but grandparents should...Read full review »
NanFergoe via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/25/22
I love listening to this podcast. I often agree with Amy, enjoy Scotts viewpoints and loved that Danielle had never seen Gilmore Girls. The last couple of episodes have included spoilers for those who haven’t seen it, so that’s a bummer for me. I’ve seen this show through several times and was...Read full review »
akc_c via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/24/22
I’m disappointed that there wasn’t any discussion of consent during this last episode. When Jess went for Rory’s belt while they were making out, Rory told him to stop MULTIPLE TIMES!! She was even trying to push him off! That scene was heartbreaking and disturbing, and I wish you all had...Read full review »
Admccu via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/22/22
Meh
I love Gilmore girls, and the podcast is fine, but definitely the podcast I listen to when I’ve caught up on all my preferred shows. I have a few qualms with it, the first being the way they recap the show. I like when they go through scene by scene, this show jumps around a lot and isn’t super...Read full review »
Becca Boo C via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/21/22
OMG you guys!! (Said in Any’s voice) I CAN NOT BELIEVE NOT ONE OF YOU KNEW HE WAS FROM KIDS IN THE HALL?!!!!! That was a HUGE cult show?!!! I was in my car yelling “WHAT?!! KIDS IN THE HALL PEOPLE! HE WAS IN KIDS IN THE HALL!!” at my phone when you were taking about the scene! Did not one of you...Read full review »
EverG999 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/20/22
I’ve loved Gilmore Girls for years and rewatch it constantly. When it comes to podcasts, I get bored easily but I Am All In does not disappoint. It’s engaging, they mix things up and if you’re a true fan, you’ll love it. Thankfully I have a job that’s mostly data entry so I’ve been able to catch...Read full review »
Luna4203 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/18/22
My wife and I listen to this podcast on our own and then discuss it every time we say the same thing we need less Amy. Her constant over talking and interrupting Scott trying to be the star of the show is making the show hard to listen to. Let Scott talk that’s what we want to hear.
lucaswieser via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/17/22
I love hearing Scott’s take on the Gilmour Girls. And Scott’s reaction to some of the characters like Max was exactly what I thought when I watched the episodes again. I was tickled to hear that Scott is doing a podcast. I love the Gilmour Girls and I was cheering for Luke and Loriela. Love the...Read full review »
ykhorsenut via Apple Podcasts · Canada · 08/15/22
Omgeee - numero uno pizza just brought me back maybe 20 years!!
Bubbles1004 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/15/22
Greetings. They are seasonal due to the fact that the melt easily. Gelson’s sell them when they’re available. Where can I send them when they’re available? (I work for Gelson’s) BTW-love the podcasts and the show 💗💗💗
switchboarder 18 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/15/22
I wanted to love this podcast. But I cannot with Scott.The only good thing about this is that it mentions the Gilmore Guys podcast, which is thee best. I’ve listened to that one a few times over and they have a much more nuanced perspective. Sad to find out how much of a misogynist Patterson is...Read full review »
siehdihsv via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/12/22
I wanted to love it. I watch this show on a constant rotation and thought this would be enjoyable to listen to. Scott is so negative all the time, I’ll listen to an episode knowing how funny it was and he finds a way to make it bad. And doesn’t let the other hosts have their own opinions. While...Read full review »
nicolepellsy via Apple Podcasts · Canada · 08/10/22
Scott - please stop using the word bipolar in the way you have in the last few episodes. It’s a serious illness that is sadly stigmatized and misunderstood. Throwing around the word and using it incorrectly is dangerous. I’m sure many of your listeners live with the disease. Describing an episode...Read full review »
funafuti325 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/09/22
The best part if this podcast was that Scott once mentioned “Gilmore Guys” podcast. I looked that up, have been hooked ever since, and never came back to this. I Am All In is soooo bad. Hard to listen to his un-nuanced opinions, lack of any real insight, talking over the other (women) hosts…....Read full review »
NYC212646 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/09/22
Update from my initial review below: after listening to other rewatch podcasts, you can see where this one falls flat sometimes. I feel like we need another member of the show to come in and join to keep the dialog moving. I enjoy the interviews with other cast members the most. I’m sorry but...Read full review »
_HMcClure via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/09/22
I am just a recent fan of the show Gilmore Girls and watched it only in the year 2020 on Netflix. It was the pandemic year and just had the need to watch anything wholesome, has great content and really funny and this show came to my mind as I did not get to watch it at their original release as...Read full review »
bats.min via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/08/22
Best podcast I have ever herd !! Down to earth people! Explain the show well , I gotta go watch again!
jaweeney via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 08/01/22
I like the professional critique and perspective that Scott brings. I also think that having the perspectives from other hosts bring a balance to the way the episodes are analyzed. I like hearing from each person for their perspective as new viewers and as longtime GG fans. My only critique is...Read full review »
Tayla Anne Barnfield via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 07/28/22
Thanks for putting this together! It’s a lot of fun to hear your reactions to the show. I love that your team includes both people who have loved the show for years and people who are watching for the first time! The back and forth about the storyline is great. I do wish the people who have...Read full review »
THD48 via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 07/28/22
Skeet Pooterson and the team always do a wonderful job of breaking down each episode and going in to interesting discussions over character development and plot lines
RamlaHussain via Apple Podcasts · United States of America · 07/25/22
Do you host a podcast?
Track your ranks and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.
See hourly chart positions and more than 30 days of history.
Get Chartable Analytics »